Group Public Affairs

 

Asia Public Affairs



Submission to IBLAC (International Business Leaders Advisory Council) by Prudential Chairman, Sir David Clementi

October 2005

Introduction


The hosting of international conferences is a relatively new business in China, but it is growing rapidly, especially in Shanghai. After more than a quarter of a century of unprecedented economic development, Shanghai has already made tremendous progress in meeting the key criteria for becoming an attractive international convention destination. Yet despite its rapid development, Shanghai’s convention industry is still in its infancy with plenty of room for continued growth.

On December 3rd, 2002, Shanghai was awarded the opportunity to host the World Expo 2010, intended to be the largest Expo ever. The hosting of the World Expo 2010 presents Shanghai with the opportunity to build on its existing strengths and advance the process of evolving into a world-class convention destination.

With this brief introduction as a background, the following paper explores how Shanghai could develop into a top-tier convention centre by taking full advantage of the World Expo 2010. The paper will begin by making some general observations about the global convention market, followed by an analysis of the current state of Shanghai’s convention industry. Opportunities brought about by the World Expo 2010 will then be examined, with several concluding recommendations.

General Observations on the Global Convention Industry

I. The Economic and Social Impact of Conventions on Host Cities

Because conventions can yield significant benefits for their host cities, the state of the convention industry in a given locale is often used by economists as a barometer of a city’s overall economic health. Some of the key benefits of convention activity are as follows;

  1. Generating direct (i.e. convention-specific) profit.
    The net profit margin of the convention industry is usually between 20% and 25%. Globally, the business of conventions and exhibitions amounts to over 280 billion U.S. dollars per year. New York, Hanover, Paris, London, and Milan are all internationally renowned conference and exhibition cities, and all have benefited significantly from the industry.


  2. Driving employment and benefiting related industries.
    International conferences not only build the convention industry; they also positively affect related industries such as transportation, hospitality, tourism, and retail. The indirect economic benefits of the industry often go far beyond the direct impact, with the ratio of direct to indirect economic benefit typically estimated at 1:9.
  3. Providing a desirable platform for companies to promote themselves.
    By providing exposure to highly-targeted consumer, business and government audiences from around the world, conventions serve as important platforms for local and regional companies to promote their brands, products, and services.
  4. Raising the international profile of the host city.
    The development of the convention industry helps promote the city as a brand. For example, Boao, a formerly unknown small town in south China's Hainan Province, has attracted an increasing number of domestic and overseas convention organisers and tourists since it successfully hosted the Boao Asia Forum in 2001.

II. Features of a Good Convention Destination

The key considerations in identifying an attractive convention destination include: access, accommodation, activities, culture, cuisine, hospitality, professionalism, safety, and weather. In each of these areas, event organizers check both for ‘basics’ and for ‘motivators.’ Basics – such as easy access and adequate accommodation – include the elements that must be in place for a location to be a convention contender. Motivators typically include unusual features – such as a particularly attractive entertainment offering – that will differentiate a location.

Overview of Shanghai’s Convention Industry


China’s convention industry is young but growing fast. According to an ICCA (International Congress & Convention Association) Statistics Report, China climbed (in terms of number of meetings hosted per year) from a world ranking of 30 in 2003 to a ranking of 15 in 20041. ICCA predicts that China has the potential to become the leading destination for meetings in the 21st century.

Shanghai enjoys a number of advantages driving its rapid growth:

  • Easy access. Shanghai is a major transportation hub for Eastern China (and East Asia more broadly). Recent enhancements such as Pudong International Airport and the Maglev train have vastly improved Shanghai’s transportation system, and further improvements to its transportation infrastructure are underway.
  • Improved accommodation, eating and retail options. Convention facilities and hotels in Shanghai have significantly improved in recent years. In addition, there is a now a wide range of restaurant and retail choices – ranging from traditional markets to high-end establishments.
  • A reputation as a dynamic place. Having maintained double-digit economic growth for over 13 years, Shanghai is known to be one of the fastest-growing cities in China. Its rank as one of the most favoured destinations for foreign direct investment – already 33 Fortune 500 companies have established regional headquarters in Shanghai – also ensures its prominence.
  • Value. Shanghai is widely perceived as a reasonably priced place to host conventions.
1 Statistics Report on International Association and Corporate Meetings Market 2003/2004, ICCA

The following statistics summarise the substantial growth of the convention industry in Shanghai over the last year:

 
  Rankings No. of Meetings Hosted % Increase
(2003-2004)
Major Asian Cities 2003 2004 2003 2004
Singapore 3 3 75 99 32.0
Seoul 16 13 36 53 47.2
Bangkok 18 17 34 46 35.3
Hong Kong 18 5 34 86 152.9
Kuala Lumpur 21 14 32 51 59.4
Taipei 33 27 18 34 88.9
Beijing 35 11 17 58 241.2
Tokyo 46 37 14 25 78.6
Shanghai 88 36 8 26 225.0

Graphic representation of the data displayed in the table above

(Source: Statistics Report on International Association and Corporate Meetings Market 2003/2004, ICCA)

Although Shanghai’s convention industry is already demonstrating robust growth, the city still faces a major challenge in developing its convention industry.

Despite having hosted several world-class conferences in recent years including the Fortune Global Forum, the Forbes CEO Conference, and the APEC Summit Meetings, Shanghai is still not perceived as a top-tier global convention destination. Many conference organizers still have concerns about the language barrier, the choice of food, cultural differences, safety considerations, and service levels. In order to compete effectively with Hong Kong and Singapore2, Shanghai will need to address this perception issue – and any substantive issues that may be contributing to this image problem.

SWOT Analysis
The following SWOT analysis summarizes the current state of the convention industry in Shanghai.

Strengths Opportunities
  • Excellent accessibility
  • Good transportation infrastructure and convention facilities
  • Increasing ability to accommodate cultural diversity
  • Appealing traditional culture
  • A reputation for dynamism
  • Good value for money
  • Strong government support
  • Safety
  • Stable political and economic environment
  • Rapid economic growth creating strong demand for large-scale conventions
  • Growing ‘Headquarters economy' bringing more multinationals to Shanghai
  • Increased openness in connection with China's WTO accession
  • The hosting of 2010 World Expo
  • Weaknesses Threats
  • Lack of brand-name conferences
  • Small annual sales volume and small share of the global market
  • Lack of well-organized and professional international promotional programs
  • Lack of efficient and competitive convention service companies
  • Lack of well-trained convention professionals
  • Continued concerns about language barriers, cultural differences, service standards

  • 2 See Appendix 1

    New Opportunities Brought by World Expo 2010


    The World Expo 2010 is a very significant opportunity for Shanghai. It is estimated that more than 70 million visitors will come to Shanghai during the Expo from May 2010 to October 2010. 5-10% of visitors will be from overseas and it is likely that visitors from almost every country and region in the world will attend. World Expo 2010 will be a bridge linking Shanghai to the rest of the world for six months. The longer term goal must be to maintain that bridge.
    • World Expo 2010 Will Position Shanghai as a Global City

      The Expo will give Shanghai significant international exposure which is expected to have a positive long-term effect on Shanghai’s image. It is very likely that Shanghai’s popularity as an international convention destination will further accelerate following the Expo.

    • 2010 Shanghai Expo Will Accelerate the Development of Urban Infrastructure

      Shanghai has entered a critical stage in terms of the development of its convention industry. According to a report from the UFI (The Union des Foires Internationales), the convention industry will undergo rapid development and play an active role in the economy when the following four criteria are met: 1) urban infrastructure is complete; 2) per capita income is above the global average; 3) the share of service sector to GDP exceeds that of manufacturing sector by over 50%; and 4) the share of international trade to GDP approaches or exceeds 10%.

      Convenient transportation and comprehensive city infrastructure are two criteria required for the development of the convention industry. The World Expo will accelerate the construction of Shanghai’s urban infrastructure and will also ‘refresh’ the overall appearance of the city. Shanghai has also made plans for the development of its transportation system over the next five years. For example, Pudong airport, aided by Hongqiao airport, will become an international airport serving 38 million passengers annually by 2010. According to the tenth ‘five-year’ plan of the Shanghai municipal government, the city will invest 20 billion RMB to improve roads, transportation, electricity and the water-supply.

      3Guoliang Xuan (2003) ‘World Expo and Shanghai’s Convention and Exhibition Industry’, in Fanghua, Wang (eds.), World Expo and Shanghai’s Economy, Shanghai Jiaotong University Press

    • The Expo Site Could Become a World-class Convention Centre.

      The Expo site, designed to house exhibits from over 200 countries and international organizations, includes 60 pavilions, 75 ancillary buildings, and 5 grand pavilions. This infrastructure will underpin the development of the convention industry in Shanghai. The 1998 Lisbon Expo is a good precedent: the former site of the Expo 98 is now a “National Park”, offering numerous attractions to the public. The international area, where the China Pavilion was located, is now one of the most important business convention centres in Portugal.

      After the World Expo 2010, buildings with distinctive features and the large pavilions should all be preserved and turned into convention venues. For example, there are proposals for the China Pavilion to become a World Expo Museum. Some of the international pavilions could also serve as venues for international cultural exchanges.

    • The Forums and Conferences Held During the World Expo 2010 Will be a Valuable Legacy for Shanghai’s Convention Industry

      It is estimated that more than 50 high level international conferences will be held in Shanghai during the Expo 2010. The forums and conferences will be particularly important to the visiting international business and political and academic communities. The hosting of the Expo forums and conferences will require considerable preparation and professional event management resources. The experience gained from these forums and conferences will make a valuable contribution to the future development of Shanghai’s convention industry.

    • World Expo 2010 Will Drive Human Resources Development for the Convention Industry

      The Expo will offer Shanghai an excellent opportunity to develop and enhance the skills of its conference and convention professionals. In August 2004, the Shanghai Municipal Personnel Bureau and the Shanghai World Expo (Group) jointly established the Shanghai World Expo Talent Development Centre to provide necessary human resources development and training for the Expo. Such training and development will ensure that Shanghai will be fully prepared to become a global convention city.

    Recommendations


    The World Expo 2010 offers Shanghai a great opportunity to present itself as a global convention destination. However, the global convention market is highly competitive and Shanghai must satisfy a number of conditions to compete more effectively.

    Firstly, to establish a leading position in the global convention industry, Shanghai should continue to improve its facilities, build its professional and human resources and set high service standards. The city has to ensure that organisers and participants experience the highest level of convenience, comfort and service. The improvement can be divided into two aspects: ‘hardware’ and ‘software’.

    • For hardware, Shanghai needs to improve its urban infrastructure, especially its transportation and hospitality infrastructure. According to a report by Jones Lang LaSalle4, Shanghai's hotel sector is experiencing a boom, fuelled by the rising number of tourists and international events. The five-star hotels in Shanghai achieved an average occupancy of 80 per cent with average room rates exceeding US$170 in 2004. The development of world-class events and attractions like the World Expo 2010 will continue to drive upper-tier lodging demand. Shanghai therefore needs to increase its upper tier hotel rooms. As for transportation, even though Shanghai has two airports, a developed railway network and modern public modes of transportation, compared with world-class meeting destinations, Shanghai still falls short of all that is required to compete fully with a London or a New York.

    • For software, Shanghai needs to raise the quality and standard of its convention offering through enhanced professionalism. A few universities in Shanghai have established convention and exhibition related courses and many training programmes are being developed. Shanghai should cooperate with international conference institutions and associations to develop international standard training programmes. Education is the ultimate solution for the shortage of convention professionals. Raising professionalism in the convention industry is a long-term process.

    Secondly, it is important that Shanghai adopts the right marketing strategy to promote itself as a desirable convention venue. A positive and progressive image of Shanghai must be presented and maintained over the long term. Efforts must be made to raise the already strong profile of the city, through media campaigns, promotional tours and films, and presentations to opinion leaders.

    Shanghai has a unique and fascinating history. Promoting the more exotic elements of the city’s past would be a useful counterpoint to the images of rampant construction and development and would serve to enhance the appeal of the city’s cultural attractions.

    4Asia Pacific Property Digest, Jones Lang LaSalle Research, April 2005

    The city with some of the world’s tallest buildings also needs to be seen as offering an intimate and authentic experience of the ‘real’ China, both old and new. Hong Kong has established itself as the hub of Asia; Shanghai has an opportunity to present itself as the ‘Heart of China’.

    Thirdly, Shanghai should endeavour to create its own conference brands. In the convention industry, a brand refers to an event that can reflect the developments and trends of a certain industry, and ultimately provide direction, inspiration and influence. The essential elements required to build a strong brand in the convention industry are: support from industry authorities and associations, scale, professional service standards, strong media presence and a consistent long-term strategy.

    Finally, Shanghai should intensify efforts to develop its service industry, especially in the key added-value sectors such as finance, insurance, commerce, transportation and telecommunications. The focus of this paper has been on the convention market which in turn can generate further trade and tourism. However, it is important to develop initiatives in a coordinated manner. Exhibitions and conferences will be beneficial to the city’s service sector. However, the development of the service industry can also help to boost the convention business. The prosperity of the convention market in Singapore and Hong Kong owes some of its success to the development of the service industries in those cities.

    Conclusion


    Shanghai is China’s most exciting city and is home to many multinationals and leading Chinese corporations. China’s adherence to its WTO commitment of opening its service and financial sector by 2006 will particularly benefit Shanghai the most through stimulating growth in the corporate conference business.

    Shanghai already has many of the required elements in place to become a leading global convention destination. However, further improvements are both necessary and possible, especially in the areas of communications and promotion; creation of conference brands, and development of convention talents.

    Certainly, perceptions do not change overnight, and it will take time to develop Shanghai into one of the world’s foremost convention cities. Shanghai has much in its favour. Shanghai has an ethos of hard work, energy and entrepreneurship and is the most vibrant city in the world’s fastest growing market. The hosting of the World Expo 2010 is likely to be a catalyst accelerating Shanghai’s progress towards its goal of becoming one of the world leading convention cities.

    Appendix: The Successful examples of Singapore and Hong Kong

    Hong Kong:
    Hong Kong is now one of the top five of meeting destinations worldwide, having risen dramatically in the last few years. It performs well against the criteria that set out in the paper. Positioning itself as the hub of Asia, “where East meets West”, it has a strong infrastructure with purpose built venues and a well managed conventions industry.

    Hong Kong has good transport links and welcomes nationals from around 170 countries visa free. The city is well known for its entrepreneurial but well regulated commercial approach.

    Hong Kong has targeted the convention market in a focused and professional way. The Hong Kong Tourism Board, as well as having nineteen offices worldwide, has specialist offices for conventions and corporate events in Los Angeles, London and Sydney, as well as Hong Kong itself.

    There is also a well organised Trade body, the Hong Kong Exhibitions and Convention Association (HKECIA). This represents the exhibition and convention industries in working with government, legislative and statutory bodies and the media. It also works to raise levels of professionalism and operational standards in the industry and promotes Hong Kong as a major international exhibition and convention centre.

    To a large extent, Hong Kong as a convention centre is also benefiting from the development of China, as it is seen as a bridge or gateway to business on the mainland. Since 2002 the number of mainland companies exhibiting in Hong Kong has risen by 95%, to over 6,000 companies. There has been an associated rise in visitor numbers from the mainland with 128,000 attending exhibitions in 2004.

    Singapore:
    Singapore is viewed by many as an ideal convention and exhibition venue. Indeed, the ICCA ranked Singapore the world's third top convention city. Singapore hosted 75 out of 3,000 conventions that the association tracked worldwide. In 2003, Singapore played host to over 500 conventions which generated more than $615 million in economic spin-offs.

    The island nation has world-class hotels offering unparalleled service, an extensive range of state-of-the-art facilities, modern communication networks, an airport with excellent air links, top-notch convention facilities that can comfortably accommodate up to 36,000 delegates, and a pool of trained convention professionals. Singapore has always been recognised as having the highest standards in the quality and services of its exhibitions and conferences. The city-state encourages the adoption of high international meetings standards, and always endeavours to champion the cause of raising industry professionalism and service quality.

    Singapore has an advanced management system for the convention industry. The Singapore Tourism Board (STB) is in charge of promoting the city-state as an ideal destination for meeting events. The Singapore Association of Convention and Exhibition Organisers and Suppliers (Saceos) and STB have been working together to promote the convention industry. Saceos aims to raise professionalism through education and training, as well as building a strong international network for its members.

      Back to Asia Public Affairs
     

    RELATED WEBSITES


    Top of page